Does 1 = 0.9999999999…? This being the internet and all, it might not surprise you to find out that the question of whether 1 = 0.9999999… (infinitely repeating 9’s) is a pretty hot area of argument across message boards and blogs, because people will argue about anything on the internet. But this argument has actually been raging for some time. I was listening to an interview with math dude Steven Strogatz on NPR’s Science Friday when I was reminded of it. Strogatz has a cool-sounding new book out called The Joy of X, that explores how math, when you disconnect it from all those ugly chalkboard proofs, is fascinatingly intertwined in every part of our lives. So why the controversy? This problem messes with our idea of what “equals” means. It just gets a little wacky when we apply logic that is meant for words to the world of numbers. There’s even a Wikipedia page dedicated to the number.  In the real number system, 1 can be shown to equal “0.999…” pretty easily, although that doesn’t necessarily explain why it is the way it is. That’s a discussion for you and your math professor. Here’s your thought experiment: Take a pie. It represents “1”, a whole pie. Cut it into 3 equal pieces, each representing 1/3, or “0.333…” repeating. Put those pieces back together and you have a whole pie, or 1 (assuming you didn’t lose any crumbs). Get it? Pretty weird. 
Pop-upView Separately

Does 1 = 0.9999999999…?

This being the internet and all, it might not surprise you to find out that the question of whether 1 = 0.9999999… (infinitely repeating 9’s) is a pretty hot area of argument across message boards and blogs, because people will argue about anything on the internet.

But this argument has actually been raging for some time. I was listening to an interview with math dude Steven Strogatz on NPR’s Science Friday when I was reminded of it. Strogatz has a cool-sounding new book out called The Joy of X, that explores how math, when you disconnect it from all those ugly chalkboard proofs, is fascinatingly intertwined in every part of our lives. So why the controversy? This problem messes with our idea of what “equals” means. It just gets a little wacky when we apply logic that is meant for words to the world of numbers. There’s even a Wikipedia page dedicated to the number. 

In the real number system, 1 can be shown to equal “0.999…” pretty easily, although that doesn’t necessarily explain why it is the way it is. That’s a discussion for you and your math professor.

Here’s your thought experiment: Take a pie. It represents “1”, a whole pie. Cut it into 3 equal pieces, each representing 1/3, or “0.333…” repeating. Put those pieces back together and you have a whole pie, or 1 (assuming you didn’t lose any crumbs). Get it? Pretty weird. 

600 Notes/ Hide

  1. foryour-information reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  2. caslovescoffee reblogged this from monilip
  3. 55trudi55 reblogged this from monilip
  4. monilip reblogged this from perelka-l
  5. huckleberrylauren reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  6. mafive reblogged this from quasxr
  7. pointyteeth reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  8. mry-j reblogged this from viva-moment
  9. viva-moment reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  10. escalator-wit reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  11. fibonacc1123 reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  12. eudaimonistic reblogged this from lucy-connelly and added:
    This is hurting my head…
  13. uglysmiles reblogged this from easy-asthe-ocean
  14. scaremeintothefuture reblogged this from mylittlechickencroissant
  15. mylittlechickencroissant reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  16. designered reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  17. supernalchiku reblogged this from inurclosets
  18. castlebuilder reblogged this from jtotheizzoe and added:
    i like the pie thing. it’s neater and simpler than the simple proof my algebra teacher showed me 8 years ago, although...
  19. jesustolostsouls reblogged this from jtotheizzoe and added:
    can thank Matlab for introducing this thinking process...seems dubious to switch between...
  20. intricatelysimple reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  21. survivingtherenaissance reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  22. queenmogwai reblogged this from bunnybundy
  23. klyz reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  24. whyyy reblogged this from bunnybundy
  25. things-to reblogged this from jtotheizzoe
  26. easy-asthe-ocean reblogged this from bunnybundy
  27. inurclosets reblogged this from sasskeladd
  28. karmainmyeye reblogged this from bunnybundy
  29. sasskeladd reblogged this from bunnybundy

Recent comments

Blog comments powered by Disqus